Our members are reporting an increase in spoofing attempts. If you receive a call from Amplify asking for secure account information, please hang up and call our contact center directly at (512) 836-5901.

Login

7 Things to Look for in a Payment Service Provider

Erin OsterhausOctober 28, 2026

Reviewed by: Julie Macaluso, VP of Commercial Banking

As a small business owner, you know how important it is to allow customers to use their preferred payment method. While some people still use cash, customers today have more ways to pay than ever before. Making the checkout process as seamless and quick as possible isn’t just great for your customers’ experience; it can also be a boost for your bottom line.

However, keeping up with all the new payment options can be complicated for a small business. That’s where a payment service provider can be helpful. 

A payment service provider gives businesses the technology and payment processing services they need to accept electronic payments. Depending on the provider, that could include everything from a countertop card reader to an online payment gateway, fraud protection options, reporting tools, and support for digital wallets.

Choosing the right provider can make processing payments feel almost effortless. But the wrong one can leave you dealing with confusing fees, limited payment options, or even technical problems that make it difficult for customers to complete a purchase. 

Before you choose a payment service provider for your small business, here are seven things to consider.

What does a payment service provider do?

A payment service provider connects your business to the financial systems necessary to accept and process electronic payments.

Whenever a customer taps a card or clicks the “pay” button on your website, several things happen behind the scenes. First, their payment information has to be securely transmitted, the transaction has to be authorized, and, of course, the money needs to make its way to your business in a timely manner.

A payment service provider and other merchant services providers provide the infrastructure that makes these payments possible. Depending on the provider and your business needs, your payment setup might include:

  • Point-of-sale (POS) hardware and software
  • Credit and debit card processing
  • Contactless or tap-to-pay capabilities
  • Digital wallet acceptance
  • Online payment processing
  • A payment gateway for e-commerce
  • A merchant account 
  • Transaction reporting
  • Fraud prevention and security tools

Depending on your business needs, you can pick and choose the features that work best for you. For example, a local contractor who primarily sends out client invoices will have very different payment needs than a restaurant, a clothing store, or an e-commerce business.

“The best payment system is one that fits the way your customers actually pay and the way your business operates,” says Julie Macaluso, Vice President of Commercial Banking at Amplify Credit Union. “You don’t necessarily need every feature enabled, but you do want a system that makes it easy for you to accept payments today and that gives you room to grow as your business expands.”

What to Look for in a Payment Service Provider

Weighing your payment service provider options? Consider these seven factors.

1. Multiple Ways for Customers to Pay

When evaluating payment service providers, start with the most important question: How do your customers actually want to pay?  

According to the Federal Reserve’s 2025 triennial payments study, cards accounted for more than three-quarters of noncash payments in 2024. Debit cards made up the majority of card payments, while the number of credit card transactions grew faster than debit cards from 2021 to 2024. Accepting credit and debit cards at your small business is therefore now more or less a basic customer expectation.

While other payment methods are also available, make sure the customers you want to reach use those methods before you decide to offer those options. You don’t need to accept every payment method available if your customers don’t usually pay by phone, for instance. The goal should be to remove as much friction from the purchase process as possible.

2. Payment Options That Work Wherever You Sell

Depending on where you conduct business, the payment methods you prioritize may change. If you run a brick-and-mortar retail shop, a countertop POS terminal might be all you need. On the other hand, if you’re a contractor or service provider who goes to customers’ homes, a mobile card reader may be the preferred method. 

Take a moment to evaluate where and how customers will need to pay you and choose the payment methods that are most convenient for that scenario.

3. Straightforward, Transparent Pricing

So far, you’ve considered your customers’ needs. Now it’s time to think about what you, as the business owner, need from the payment service provider.

Most business owners would likely prefer simple and straightforward pricing from a payment service provider. When you’re evaluating candidates, be sure to check whether they charge transaction fees or monthly service fees.

Are there any equipment costs associated with using their service? Any other additional fees? 

Before you sign any agreement, get a clear explanation of the entire pricing structure. Compare different providers based on what you expect to pay overall, not just a single percentage listed on a sales sheet.

4. Security and Fraud Protection

When you accept electronic payments, that means you are handling sensitive financial information. As such, security should always be a major consideration with any payment service provider you are thinking of using.

As part of your vetting process, ask any potential provider how they protect payment data and what tools they offer to reduce fraud. Depending on the system, protections may include encryption, tokenization, EMV chip technology, or fraud monitoring.

But don’t think security for customer payments rests solely with the payment provider. Be sure to understand what your security responsibilities are, too. Businesses that accept or process card payments are subject to the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard, or PCI DSS, although specific compliance and validation requirements depend on how your business accepts and handles card data.

5. Tools That Make Running Your Business Easier 

You might be shopping for a payment provider primarily to process customer payments, but these systems might offer other tools that can be useful for your business. For instance, many modern POS and merchant services platforms also provide:

  • Sales reporting and analytics
  • Inventory tracking
  • Customer management
  • Digital receipts
  • Invoicing
  • Recurring payments
  • Employee management
  • Gift card or loyalty programs

Tools like these can help reduce manual data entry, saving you time and giving you a clearer picture of what’s going on across your business.

6. Reliable Access to Your Money

When you have a successful sale, that doesn’t help your cash flow until the money reaches your account. When investigating payment service providers, it’s important to ask how long it typically takes for processed payments to settle and become available for your business.

If your business has tight cash flow, even a small timing difference can have a big impact when you’re trying to process payroll, pay rent, purchase inventory, or pay vendors.

7. Support When Something Goes Wrong

Like most technology, payment services software and equipment are convenient…until it stops working.

Choosing a provider that has excellent customer service and quick response times when you have an issue can save you a lot of stress. So, before you finalize your choice, find out what type of assistance is available, when their customer service line is open, and if there are additional costs for technical support.

“When something goes wrong with your payment system, you need to know where to turn,” Macaluso says. “Good service isn’t just about getting your account set up. It’s also about having support available when your business needs it.” 

Choose a Payment Service Provider That Can Grow with You

Choosing the right payment service provider can enable your business to accept the payment methods your customers want to use, process those payments securely, keep track of transactions, and make the entire purchase experience more convenient for everyone involved.  But there’s no single payment setup that’s right for every business. Before you make a decision, consider what’s most important to you and your customers. The goal is simple: make it easy for customers to pay you and make it easy for your business to manage the money once they do.

Merchant Services that Connect You

Amplify partners with Fiserv, a comprehensive payment service provider. Take your small business to the next level!

Erin Osterhaus

Erin is a personal finance writer based in Austin, Texas. Her work has been featured on TechRepublic, Yahoo Small Business, and Entrepreneur.com. She’s been passionate about helping others manage their money since she successfully paid off $60,000 in student loans in four years. When she’s not writing, Erin loves reading, studying languages, and spending time with her family.